Pay-Per-Lead vs. Performance Marketing: What Contractors Should Know
· Lead Generation · 6 min
Short answer: pay-per-lead services are paid for the number of leads they send you, so they are rewarded for volume, not for jobs you close. Many sell the same homeowner to two or three contractors. Running your own ads, with a partner paid on results, usually costs less per booked job and builds an asset you keep.
How do pay-per-lead services work?
A lead service runs its own ads under a generic brand, collects homeowner requests, and sells each request to contractors in that area. You pay per lead whether or not the homeowner answers, books or buys. The ads, the data and the audience belong to the lead service.
What are the problems with pay-per-lead for contractors?
- Shared leads. The same homeowner is often sold to you and two competitors, so you are in a price war before you have parked the truck.
- Wrong incentive. A company paid per lead is paid to inflate the lead count, not to bring you jobs.
- Junk costs you twice. You pay for the lead, then your crew pays again with a wasted estimate visit.
- Nothing to keep. When you stop paying, you have no ad account, no data and no brand recognition to show for it.
What is performance marketing for contractors?
Performance marketing means ads run under your own brand and in your own ad accounts, measured on booked jobs and revenue instead of lead count. A good setup adds a qualifying question to the ad (service needed, timeline, property) so tire-kickers filter themselves out, and replies to every lead in under a minute so you win the job.
Which one costs less?
Per lead, a shared lead can look cheap. Per booked job, it usually is not. Compare: 50 leads at a 10% close rate and 25 leads at a 20% close rate bring the same number of jobs, but the second needs half the calls, half the estimates and half the truck rolls. Quality beats volume.
How Trofys charges
Trofys never charges per lead. Depending on the plan, fees combine a setup and/or monthly retainer with a share of the revenue our ads bring in, so we only do well when you close jobs. The ad accounts, website, pipeline and data stay in your name. Book a free strategy call to see if it fits your business.